---
title: "Can Your Thyroid Struggle Even With Plenty of Iodine? | Elwin Robinson"
url: https://elwinrobinson.com/insights/thyroid-plenty-of-iodine-halogens
description: "A struggling thyroid isn't always short of iodine. Too much fluoride, bromine or chlorine can push the iodine out of your thyroid gland."
lang: en
---

Hormonal Optimization

# Can Your Thyroid Struggle Even With Plenty of Iodine?

5 November 2026 · Elwin Robinson

Image: Can Your Thyroid Struggle Even With Plenty of Iodine? (https://elwinrobinson.com/insights/thyroid-plenty-of-iodine-halogens.png)

## The Executive Summary

- 1 If your thyroid is struggling, a lack of iodine is one possible reason, but an excess of fluoride, bromine or chlorine can also push out the iodine you have.
- 2 I wouldn't try to push the halogens out with high-dose iodine, because too much iodine can cause hypothyroidism as much as too little can.
- 3 I want to reduce the chlorine, bromine and fluoride we're taking in, and one of many reasons is that they can push iodine out of your thyroid.

Is your thyroid struggling, and is your first thought that you need more iodine? A lack of iodine is one real reason a thyroid doesn't work properly, but it isn't always the reason. Sometimes the problem is that you're taking in too much fluoride, bromine or chlorine, which can push the iodine out of your thyroid gland.

Iodine is one of the two things your thyroid builds its hormone out of, and the other is tyrosine, an amino acid. T4, the reserve form of thyroid hormone, is tyrosine with four atoms of iodine, and T3, the active form, is tyrosine with three. Of those two building blocks, iodine is by far the better known, and for good reason. A hundred to a hundred and fifty years ago, iodine deficiency was common enough that parts of the United States were known as the goiter belt, a goiter being a swelling of the thyroid gland in response to a real deficiency. That's why salt was iodized, and it's why iodine in most people's diets is now higher than it was.

Below I'll go through how fluoride, bromine and chlorine can push iodine out of your thyroid, and why I wouldn't try to fix that by taking more iodine.

## Iodine and the other halogens: why your body mixes them up

Iodine, fluoride, bromine and chlorine belong to the same class of elements, the halogens. The problem is that your body can easily mistake them for each other, and we have access to far higher levels of the other three than we did through most of our history.

Fluoride is in the water and the toothpaste, and chlorine is used widely to sanitize water. Bromine turns up in flour and is often put in bread and various other foods, and these days it's often used to keep pools clean instead of chlorine.

The thyroid gland tends to be a magnet for this whole group of elements, so they don't spread evenly through your body.

## How fluoride, bromine and chlorine can push iodine out of your thyroid

When you take in an excess of fluoride, bromine or chlorine, they can go into your thyroid gland and displace the iodine, and that stops your thyroid working properly. Over time, steady exposure leaves less iodine available for your thyroid to make its hormone with, and since iodine is one of the two building blocks, that matters a great deal.

## It comes down to how much you take in

What matters here is whether you're taking in an excess of the other halogens. I believe it's speculated without too much controversy these days that an excess can displace the iodine in your thyroid, and I think the only thing that's controversial is how you define excessive.

Halogen displacement is one thing that can go wrong with a thyroid, not the only one. Besides a lack of iodine, a lack of tyrosine can leave your thyroid without enough of what it needs to make its hormone. Autoimmunity is another: that's where your immune system attacks your thyroid gland, and then the gland can't make enough thyroid hormone.

## Why I wouldn't take more iodine to push the other halogens out

If the other halogens can push iodine out of your thyroid, it might seem logical to take a lot more iodine to push them back out. High-dose iodine is promoted partly on exactly those grounds, that iodine competes with the other halogens for the same sites.

For years I followed the high-dose iodine school. The argument was that high-dose iodine could clear bromine and fluoride out of the thyroid, and I took 10 to 20 milligrams a day. Every time I took it, I felt cold afterward, and people told me it was a detox reaction. In fact the iodine was suppressing my thyroid function, and I ended up with full-blown medical hypothyroidism, which is low thyroid function. I might have ended up there anyway, that's always hard to say, but the high-dose iodine didn't help at all, and I suspect it probably made it worse.

Where I've come down pretty firmly is that too much iodine can cause hypothyroidism as much as too little can. That isn't a universally held view, and I'm not saying iodine always causes hypothyroidism or that you should avoid it in all food. It's hard to overdo iodine through food and very easy to do through supplements. And there's a significant group of people who've brought on a low thyroid, and with it a low metabolism in their cells, by taking too much iodine.

I'm sharing this article as education, not medical advice.

## What I'd do about the halogens instead

I want to reduce the chlorine, bromine and fluoride we're taking in, and the way they can push iodine out of your thyroid is one of many reasons why. I go through the halogens, along with the other toxins we take in, in The Detox Paradox, the detox book in my Rejuvenate Blueprint series. You'll find it at https://rejuvenateblueprint.com/.

So if your thyroid isn't working properly and you're taking in a lot of fluoride, bromine or chlorine, don't assume the answer is more iodine. You may have plenty of iodine, and it may be getting displaced because you're taking in even more of the other stuff.

## Related Insights

Hormonal Optimization

### Signs of Too Much Omega-6 That Look Like Unrelated Problems

Read Analysis
https://elwinrobinson.com/insights/signs-of-too-much-omega-6

Hormonal Optimization

### Why More Selenium Isn't Better: My Level Hit 310

Read Analysis
https://elwinrobinson.com/insights/more-selenium-not-better

Hormonal Optimization

### Why Do Healthy Habits Release Toxins From Storage?

Read Analysis
https://elwinrobinson.com/insights/healthy-habits-release-toxins-from-storage

I use privacy-friendly analytics to see which pages help people. Can I also use cookies and record anonymous visits to improve the site? Anything you type in forms is never recorded.

Privacy Policy: https://elwinrobinson.com/privacy

## Structured data

```json
{
  "@context": "https://schema.org",
  "@type": "Person",
  "@id": "https://elwinrobinson.com/#person",
  "name": "Elwin Robinson",
  "url": "https://elwinrobinson.com",
  "description": "Author of the Rejuvenate Blueprint book series, host of the Rejuvenate Podcast, and founder of Advanced Health Genetics and Hormetics.",
  "jobTitle": "Health researcher, author and podcast host",
  "sameAs": [
    "https://youtube.com/@elwinrobinson",
    "https://instagram.com/therealelwin",
    "https://x.com/ElwinRobinson",
    "https://linkedin.com/in/elwinrobinson",
    "https://www.amazon.com/stores/author/B0GWWXWD12",
    "https://open.spotify.com/show/4isNJt0mGI36H6wrLfEcWB",
    "https://www.facebook.com/therealelwin"
  ],
  "affiliation": [
    {
      "@type": "Organization",
      "name": "Advanced Health Genetics",
      "url": "https://advancedhealthgenetics.com"
    },
    {
      "@type": "Organization",
      "name": "Hormetics",
      "url": "https://hormetics.health"
    }
  ],
  "knowsAbout": [
    "genetics",
    "nutrigenomics",
    "root causes of chronic disease",
    "hormones",
    "detoxification"
  ]
}
```